A Case for Irony (Tanner Lectures on Human Values) by Jonathan Lear

By Jonathan Lear

In 2001, Vanity Fair declared that the Age of Irony was once over. Joan Didion has lamented that the U.S. within the period of Barack Obama has turn into an "irony-free zone." Jonathan Lear in his 2006 publication Radical Hope appeared into America’s middle to invite how could we dispose ourselves if we got here to think our lifestyle was once coming to an finish. the following, he mobilizes a squad of philosophers and a psychoanalyst to once more forge an intensive approach ahead, by means of arguing that no really human existence is feasible with no irony.

Becoming human shouldn't be taken without any consideration, Lear writes. it truly is whatever we accomplish, whatever we get the hold of, and prefer Kierkegaard and Plato, Lear claims that irony is likely one of the crucial instruments we use to do that. For Lear and the contributors in his Socratic discussion, irony isn't approximately being cool and indifferent like a participant in a Woody Allen movie. That, as Johannes Climacus, one among Kierkegaard’s pseudonymous authors, places it, “is anything in basic terms assistant professors assume.” in its place, it's a renewed dedication to residing heavily, to experiencing each disruption that shakes us out of our ordinary methods of tuning out of existence, with all its vicissitudes. whereas many over the centuries have argued another way, Lear claims that our emotions and wishes have a tendency towards order, a constitution that irony shakes us into seeing. Lear’s exchanges together with his interlocutors advance his claims, whereas his reports as a working towards psychoanalyst deliver an emotionally gripping measurement to what's at stake—the psychic expenditures and merits of dwelling with irony.

Show description

Read or Download A Case for Irony (Tanner Lectures on Human Values) PDF

Best psychoanalysis books

Infinite Thought: Truth And The Return To Philosophy (Continuum Impacts)

Inspired through Plato, Lucretius, Heidegger, Lacan and Deleuze, Badiou is a critic of either the analytical and the postmodern faculties of concept. His paintings spans the diversity of philosophy, from ethics, to arithmetic to technological know-how, psychoanalysis, politics and artwork. His writing is rigorous and startling and takes no prisoners.

General Index (The Collected Works of C. G. Jung, Volume 20)

A very entire index by way of paragraph numbers. yes topics are taken care of in separate sub-indexes in the basic Index. those comprise alchemy, animals, the Bible, shades, Freud, Jung, and numbers.

NOTE: This quantity is just on hand retail purely in PDF structure. examining it in Adobe Reader turns out to create error. Adobe electronic variations works, as does Sumatra 2. 6. nine pre-release.

Sur les névroses de guerre

En septembre 1918, à Budapest, le Ve Congrès foreign de psychanalyse est notamment consacré aux névroses de guerre.

Eros and civilization : a philosophical inquiry into Freud

During this vintage paintings, Herbert Marcuse takes as his place to begin Freud's assertion that civilization is predicated at the everlasting subjugation of the human instincts, his reconstruction of the prehistory of mankind - to an interpretation of the fundamental traits of western civilization, stressing the philosophical and sociological implications

Additional info for A Case for Irony (Tanner Lectures on Human Values)

Sample text

No culture is stronger than its ability to pass on its values to the next generation, so this is a conversation born of social anxiety. Anxious representatives of the social practice are turning to Socrates for help, and Socratic examination is his response. It does not leave them empty-handed. Rather, they are convinced that they need to find a proper teacher for themselves. ” Socrates agrees to meet again tomorrow so they can all begin to search for the best Â�possible teacher (201a–c). Do I have any takers for the bet that should they find that teacher, not only will he not know what courage is, but he will not know what teaching is either?

So being human would be a matter of becoming human—the practical task of achieving human excellence—and this would be learning what it means to be human. But the practical knowledge that is human excellence contains a moment of ignorance internal to it. Part of what it is to be, say, courageous is to recognize that one’s practical understanding of courage is susceptible to ironic disruption. Part of what it is to be courageous is courageously to face the fact that living courageously will inevitably entangle one in practices and pretenses and Â�possible acts all of which are susceptible to the question, what does any of that have to do with courage?

There is something about my practical identity that breaks my practical identity apart: it seems larger than, disruptive of, itself. This is the experience of irony. Call this an existential crisis if you will, but this is not how the expression is normally used. In—forgive the expression—a normal existential crisis, life comes to seem empty, and I throw it all overboard in order to do something dramatically different. 23 By contrast, in the ironic experience, it is my fidelity to teaching that has brought my teacherly activities into question.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.14 of 5 – based on 40 votes